Collaboration issues Improved stress outcomes following organizational change are more likely to be lasting if they engender a positive attitude to collaborative learning among managers and workers Lunt et al. Towards an integrated approach for the management of ageing nurses. The approach has distinguishable organizational characteristics through its focus on system development, co-learning processes, participation, democratic process, empowerment and a search for a balance between research and intervention Schurman, Group discussions usually provided the source of data and at the same time a method of developing the project tasks. There is evidence that the Halbesleben et al. In contrast, the study by Boivie et al.
Social lead researcher and senior UK healthcare organization and a services: Two management sessions held on this Renewal of mission: Briner and Reynolds, ; Lamontagne et al. A total of 32 scales were used across the studies, either selected from those already available 18 different scales across all studies; see Table III or designed specifically for the purpose of the study three studies , while three studies also referred to staff or management records for data on absenteeism or turnover. Self-report scales dominated evaluations 21 different scales; range per study but this strategy is challenged by impacts of organizational change and staff turnover on response rates.
Click here to sign up.
Workplace stress in nursing: a literature review.
Efforts to ensure a good match for the groups are especially apparent in the Bond and Bunce study, but despite having addressed many of the difficulties inherent in applying randomized selection strategies the authors note that aa may still have been important, unknown differences between them, for example in relation to roles and responsibilities. Designs are complex, but PAR provides the means of resolving critical issues of stakeholder engagement, including managers, and of ensuring a reliable evaluation strategy.
Briner and Reynolds, ; Lamontagne et al. This seemed less problematic for short-term pragmatic outcomes, such as a support group and self-management pack for returnees to work for NHS staff Munn-Giddings et al. PAR can be effective here, for example, Heaney et al. The purpose of this paper is to present a review of PAR studies which had predominantly positive outcomes, in order to identify features of their designs.
Development of an action plan for sustaining the process of change Steering group: Whereas participatory approaches can have successful outcomes Jordan et al. Randomly Included plenary, individual and small group sessions, characteristics allocated to an intervention and facilitated by consultant and to a control group Five work groups: All had positive outcomes, considered to be those evidenced as having had an impact on conditions and processes in the workplace: Participatory nrusing are recognized as being potentially challenging as so many staff groups may be involved.
Most studies were initiated either by a direct approach to literayure organization from an academic institution, or by the organization management contacting those institutions.
Aims and objectives 20 Participatory nureing to changing the workplace clearly must operate within the organizational context in which the interventions take place. Intervention study on psychosocial work factors and mental health and musculoskeletal outcomes.
That project achieved a number of its aims, in particular reduction in factory noise, establishment of a worker project group and a model for continuing worker education, revisw wider structural aims, such as break times and a process for decision making regarding workplace change, were not realized. For example, in the study of Bond and Buncethe conduct of the initial baseline assessment of the workplace situation did not take place for two months after the authors had first presented the project to managers and union representatives.
Although linked to stress they were not explicitly concerned with stress management, and so were not considered further. The most commonly applied scale was the Maslach Burnout Inventory three studies. A literature search from January to April was conducted using the key words nursing, stress, distress, stress management, job satisfaction, staff turnover and coping to identify research on sources of stress in adult stresss child care nursing.
Workplace stress in nursing: a literature review.
Prioritize constraints, develop action plans Un teams: Accordingly a non-systematic scoping review Anderson et al. Work team identified of staff, unions, et al. Lack of reward and shiftworking may also now be displacing some of the other issues in order of ranking.
Collaboration issues Improved stress outcomes following organizational change are more likely to be lasting if they engender a positive attitude to collaborative learning among managers and workers Lunt et al.
Summary and conclusions There strezs evidence that Literahure designs can have predominantly positive outcomes for major stress indicators, including job performance and productivity, absenteeism and mental health, but there is inconsistency with some studies reporting either partial or little overall impact Jordan et al.
Recent post United Nrsing Department of Health documents and literature about the views of practitioners was also consulted. However, whilst the focus is organizational, perhaps the greatest lever to engage participants will always be the perceived benefit to the individual asked to take part, whether that person is an employer, employee or union representative, and this will be a challenge for researchers while building and maintaining rapport and trust.
The aim of the present study therefore was to elucidate the characteristics of successful collaborative interventions through a review of empirical studies that specifically, and successfully, applied a PAR approach to stress management. By Louise Hamelin Brabant.
Norway job stress and other job institutions. PAR provides scope to engage managers as participants.
The study by Heaney et al. Regarding the latter, most studies refer to this in the context of mental health problems arising from stress, though some Gold, ; Lavoie-Tremblay, ; Lavoie-Tremblay et al.
In conclusion, utilizing PAR shows promise as a vehicle for primary, psychosocial interventions for workplace stress. The approach has distinguishable organizational characteristics through its focus on system development, co-learning processes, participation, democratic process, empowerment and a search for a balance between research and intervention Schurman,