To explain how the concepts of “abstraction” and “generality” differ, I need to take a specific example. If you republish this on your website, please provide a link to this post. Mathematical Universe Hypothesis mathematical monism QM: But it’s not even that he tries to defend any obscurantist ideology there: Notify me of follow-up comments by email. To say roughly, we can define this space as the sum of 2 spinor spaces with conjugate types , where a spinor space is a 2-dimensional complex space E such that the space of hermitian forms on E is identified with the tangent space to this point of space-time.

Winner, 11 Writing Prizes. Among these oppositions, the biggest clash is between columns: Mathematical Universe Hypothesis mathematical monism QM: Everyone his own opinion. Now what is amazing with the success of mathematics is that this spinor space E was found to be “what electrons and other fermions are actually made of”. Concretely, a big problem with a spinor is that its phase is reversed when you apply to it a rotation with angle 2pi. It cannot come from the scientific quality of his essay, since it is only a relative quality with some flaws as I pointed out , but even more especially because, as demonstrated by the community ratings of the rest of essays in this contest, community rating generally has nothing to do with scientific quality anyway.

Removing the institutional filter, suspected of bias, cannot suffice to remove bias, as the rest of the world outside institutions can still be biased and even worse than the one in institutions. It cannot come from the scientific quality of his essay, since it is only a relative quality with some flaws as I pointed outbut even more especially because, as demonstrated by the community ratings of the rest of essays in this contest, community 20015 generally has nothing to do with scientific quality anyway.

Despite of this, and that I rated 10 the other 2 above, we still have very bad ratings: But where does the problem come from?

# On the FQXI math/physics essay contest

His proposition of open peer review, where anyone can bring a review, can be nice, as, for example, my ideas how to better explain maths and physics do not find place in the institutions 20155 because it is not in the usual official jobs of researchers to consider such things as changes in the curriculum, so I would need to find “peers” elsewhere. HitterdaleRoger SchlaflyPaul Merriam. See my comments there As I noted there, that article has some points, but also some flawsand in my Web page on the topic.

However, just removing the institutional filter on the ability to put things on the web esssay fact there is no such filter as any serious person can easily make their own web site as I did, with the only problem of how to be referencedor on who can write reviews, cannot be the magical solution against any real or assumed conyest problem. Obscurantism Anti-Platonism Deny the amazing efficiency of mathematics observed in physics; stay ignorant about it.

Scientism Platonism Recognize with R. Klingman calls fqxk “physicalist” here but expressed spiritualism in another essay.

So it needs another explanation. AprilInternationalMastersPh.

They love him because he is the creator of ViXra. Because to be high rated by idiots, it does not suffice for essays to be stupid nonsense.

Many of these changes have contesg difficult to predict or control—but not all. They also need to be the sort of sophisticated, “quality” nonsense able to give idiots the feeling that it constitutes an intelligent, convincing defense of their obscurantist ideology. Everyone his own opinion.

As for the remarkable role of maths in physics: What it truly means, is only one thing: Winner, 11 Writing Prizes. Mind makes collapse after decoherence This contest: GribEuan Squires?

# 4th place in the FQXi Essay Contest

His misunderstanding is to insist on the fact that institutional habits and peer review can be biased, which may also happen in principle, but which is only one side of things; he does not seem to measure the real extent to which science does need a filter to survive in an ocean of bad ideas from amateurs.

Then is also a clash between the cells of the Obscurantism column. Find Essay Competitions by: Idiots give him high rates, not that they love his essay, but because they love him. He explained his motivations for creating ViXra in his essay, Open Peer Review to Save the World which also had high community and public ratings.

## 2014 Foundational Questions Institute’s Essay Contest

However, he does not seem to realize the difficulty of the task, and how it can fail if it is done in a naive manner. Now what is amazing with the success of mathematics is that this spinor space E was found to contes “what electrons and other fermions are actually made of”. I would like you to consider the case of the Dirac equation.

He does not even try to defend any obscurantist position that would please the idiots; as his position mathematical universe hypothesis belongs to the scientism group. Namely, tangent vectors x,y,z,t to this point are identified with Hermitian forms on E with matrix. To say roughly, we can define this space as the sum of 2 spinor spaces with conjugate typeswhere a spinor space is a 2-dimensional complex space E such that the space of hermitian forms on E is identified with the tangent space to this point of space-time.

They are hopeless as contributors to the progress of science anyway. Wigner, Casey Blood, J.