In David Birnbaum’s story “The Catbird Seat” he uses several examples all throughout his story from his own personal experiences. David Birnbaum’s personal experiences makes his essay, “The Catbird Seat”, even more convincing because it holds true and provides evidence by supplying examples. I think that his reliance on personal experience makes his essay seem less convincing. I always thought that his first hand experiences made it more credible, but I never thought about thinking of the opinions of other disabled people. He shows personal experiences that he has been through during his life that shows the advantages of being disabled. He may never get use of his limbs back.

His goal for the essay seems to inform the readers as well as educate them on the life of the disabilities. His personal experiences allow the reader to understand what it is like to have a disability and how people treat you. I think his personal experience makes it a little more convincing. He gets out of speeding tickets, showing up late to work. Being handicapped gives him credibility in this essay because he is experiencing it first hand.

He worked his disability to his advantages by making the customs lady feel guilty, when she asked what was in the bag.

Reply Your comment will be posted after it is approved. With a hour delay you will have to wait for 24 hours due to heavy workload and high demand – for free. Certain people did let him get away with many things. If someone told us that blind trumps wheelchair, wheelchair trumps pregnant, pregnant trumps old, old trumps whatever else, we’d probably be offended at this hierarchy they established. People almost always give disabled people and people in wheelchairs the benefit of the doubt and naturally give them the privileges that David describes thesiss this story.


exemplification response essay | Written Essays

Plus, a story completely devoid of any specific examples would be far more uninteresting than the story Birnbaum wrote. Such as when he talks about he cuts people off and bumps up to the front of the line because he feels that he should have special privileges because he is in a wheel chair. So, he decides to take advantage of his situation instead of indulging in self-pity.

the catbird seat david birnbaum thesis

They need to respect others and not try to get things that they do not deserve. Only the users having paid subscription get the unlimited number of samples immediately. He is surprised that somebody had actually said something about it.

The fact that he went through every single one of these struggles, run-ins, and devious acts makes his story very convincing. He renewed his drivers license without waiting. He thinks he has it made. Quadriplegia — Paralysis of all four limbs; tetraplegia. I also agree with what you’re saying.

I agree with what you say because he does try to get away with things because of his disability. I seem to have interpreted the question in a different way than you. I xeat that Birnbaum does test the limits of his situation and privileges. This eeat us to tye how he has come to the conclusion he has, because of his experiences with the pecking order. I, however, don’t agree with the viewpoint he takes on his disability.


the catbird seat david birnbaum thesis

Usually when he does something like that, people apologize and let him through, holding the door or making sure he is okay. Coming from someone who it actually happened to.

His examples open your eyes to the world around you. I have five of these red baskets in tthe hallway closet. Real life experiences convince people.

The Catbird Seat

He uses is as an advantage but by being rude. This is kind of random but “The Catbird Seat” by David Birnbaum was a good story displaying exemplification. There is no way to deny it. He provides no other point of view in his examples, so I feel that degrades his credibility. Hearing about his personal experiences our eyes are open to their struggles.

Exploiting The Catbird Seat Essay Sample

His first example is when he was still in the hospital he cut off a group full of riders who had been waiting for the elevator, one of which being pregnant but all let him pass. Literature Review Dissertation chapter: Some people that I have talked to about how the wheel chair changed their life have different responses. I think that his reliance on personal experience makes his essay seem less convincing.