Where there is no information: Surprisingly, even the need for shelter was not as bad as feared, as most of the 80, displaced people moved in with relatives for the first few days. Perhaps goods should have been given only to women, as at one point UNICEF had decided to do, or only to children, or only through churches. Could the clue be in the agency stickers plastering every aid vehicle in Goma, and the agency logos everywhere? Houses for rent were available, and those who had money rented rooms and space towards the west of the town.

Eventually, some of this was done. Complex justifications are developed. Many cross the border intonearby Rwanda and become refugees therewith little food, water or clothes. If we had given money There is abundant evidence from around the globe that post-disaster economies revive quickly if everyone has a little money to spend. No lorries or stores are needed, and the logistics are certainly simpler. Developing micro-enterprise in refugee camps:

Despite this, agencies gave food, and the addition of food aid to the market depressed prices and impoverished those who were already selling in the market.

mount nyiragongo volcano case study

Mental health needs in Palestine. Complex justifications are developed.

The case for cash: Goma after the Nyiragongo eruption – ODI HPN

Why did aid agencies ignore all their rhetoric about responding to the needs of people, and just give what they thought the people needed, not what they said they wanted? New aid workers are warned by older and wiser colleagues never to give cash to beneficiaries. The humanitarian situation and response in the OPT. Where there is no information: The town is a busy commercial centre, a hive of economic activity and the main point of entry for goods from the outside world for much of eastern Congo.


mount nyiragongo volcano case study

The case for cash: Eventually, some of this was done. Nyiragongo Published by Guset User The humanitarian crisis in the occupied Palestinian territory: Why, then, did agencies continue to supply these items, even when it was obvious that they had become currency, and a debased one at that, as the continuing supply of new sheets and pots reduced their sale value to virtually zero and impoverished the people who normally sold them?

Mount Nyiragongo 2002 eruption case study

Cost-recovery in the health sector: Humanitarian response in the occupied Palestinian territory: For this major and crucial need, only cash would do. International humanitarian aid to the Palestinians. Palestinian NGOs and the second Intifada. At least 45 people died and s are http: Developing minimum standards vllcano education in emergencies.

Mount Nyiragongo eruption case study – Document in A Level and IB Geography

Could the clue be in the agency stickers plastering every aid vehicle in Goma, and the agency logos everywhere? There was no immediate danger of starvation. If the beneficiaries tell us clearly, as they did, time and again in Goma, that what they needed was cash, why did aid agencies persist in giving them goods?


mount nyiragongo volcano case study

Money does not even have to be given free though the food, pots and sheets were. And that was the one thing aid agencies would not, indeed could not, give.

Monut can publish your book online for free in a few minutes! Families were made to line up for hours to collect meticulously counted and packaged items, and the length of the procedure alone led to frustration, and ultimately to temptation and mlunt.

Lessons in Post-Disaster Assistance from Goma, unpublished case study, There was overwhelming evidence that, within a day or two, the only value of another plastic sheet or another cooking-pot was in its sale. If it golcano in the economy somewhere then it is doing its job.

Case study of a Volcanic eruption : Mt. Nyiragongo

Create your own flipbook. But perhaps the aid community could be radical and say that people, especially adults, nyidagongo a right to misuse their cash. Case study of a Volcanic eruption: Read the Text Version. Would the misuse of money in Goma have been any worse than the misuse of goods?