Jennifer rated it really liked it Dec 22, This can be shown via examples from the Scriptures. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. I’d almost rather see Jesus and Paul as innovating the corporate election of Israel to graft in the Gentiles – this subverting expectations of large and smaller i. The Chosen People comes highly recommended! So it is not surprising that this concept plays such an important role in Pauline theology.
Preview — The Chosen People by A. I commend Thornhill for his investigative work and excellent treatment of the source documents in presenting his thesis. Jeremy rated it really liked it Feb 08, Aogu Fujihashi marked it as to-read Jun 11, Chadwick Thornhill PhD, Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary is an exploration assigned the task of carefully guiding the reader through the early Jewish literature of the Second Temple period, specifically to examine how it discusses the concept of election in relation to the people of God. An insightful, well argued, and compelling book on Judaism and election. Nov 06, Steve rated it really liked it.
It also gives insight into the tenuous political relationship with the Roman thormhill as an occupied territory. An Exegetical and Theological Study of Romans 9: Sherif Gendy is currently reading it Nov 19, The author argues that election is primarily corporate, and that Paul falls in line with STJ.
Dr. Chad Thornhill
Occasionally, I am asked whether I identify as a Calvinist or an Arminian. We need more books like this, that set Paul’s letters in their context.
In other words, if you do the works specified under the covenant, you show yourself to be within the covenant as a child of God, but if you do not, then your failure puts you outside the covenant. Thornhill’s The Chosen People is a bit dense, since it was originally his dissertation, but trudging through the book has changed the way I read Paul. Election and Responsibility The author does a good job of laying out who was considered to be elect and in what way election was both corporate and individual.
Hoyt Denton added it Apr 18, Paperbackpages. Still, when the concept of election explicitly relates to the individual, Thornhill argues that the literature of the Second Temple period predictably emphasizes the character or role of the individual, rather than the salvation.
This book is not yet diszertation on Listopia. This can be shown via examples from the Scriptures. Theodros marked it as to-read Dec 28, Disssertation Brooks marked it as to-read Dec 14, Jan 01, Dustin Ragland rated it liked it.
Are you tired of hearing the free will v. Both were acting in opposition to the covenant they entered, yet Paul refers to them as brethren, demonstrating their position within the covenant community, rebuking and admonishing so to turn them toward a proper life in Christ.
Thornhill looks at the markers or conditions that defined various groups, and considers whether election was viewed by ancient authors as merited, given graciously or both.
Nick rated it it was amazing Nov 07, Thornnill you read Ephesians 1, Romans 8, etc.? Thanks for telling us about the problem.
The reader will certainly learn a lot as the framework is being built to discuss Paul. What is the purpose of good works?
The Chosen People: Election, Paul and Second Temple Judaism by A. Chadwick Thornhill
Depending on your doctrinal understanding, the lack of trust in the covenant-making God places or shows one outside the covenant see Hebrews 6: As a Pharisee, Paul would have been well-versed in the thorbhill of Judaic instruction, yet we see with the Damascus road incident, a complete shift in perspective. In this careful and provocative study, Chad Thornhill considers how Second Temple understandings of election influenced key Pauline texts.
Neil Kruger rated it really liked it Dec 11, An insightful, well argued, thornhikl compelling book on Judaism and election. Disclosure of Material Connection: And I usually reply that I’m neither because I believe predestination is not primarily about salvation.
Chad A. Thornhill MD
Those interested in a similar fate will embrace this book with open arms. While, being a compatibilist believing that divine sovereignty and human freedom coincideI feel that Thornhill’s work strengthens the case for human responsibilty.
Want to Read saving…. Ben rated it really liked it Sep 01, Human agency – in all its complexity – is explored and I think there is fhornhill significant substance to the idea of human “freedom” in STJ.